Traffic rules are essential for maintaining order and safety on the roads. But what happens when you’re fined by the traffic police for an offence? Can you be fined again on the same day for the same reason? This is a question many drivers in India are curious about, and in this article, we’ll dive deep into this issue, explaining the laws, exceptions, and practical implications of being fined multiple times.
WATCH | Stop Paying Traffic Fines
What Does the Law Say?
The Indian legal system prohibits being punished twice for the same offence, thanks to the principle of “double jeopardy.” However, traffic violations work slightly differently, and there are specific rules that dictate when you can and cannot be fined twice in a single day.
Here are the key points to keep in mind:
- General Rule:
- Traffic police cannot fine you twice for the same offence in one day if you’ve already paid the penalty.
- For example, if you’ve been fined for not wearing a helmet in the morning and received a challan, you cannot be penalized again for the same reason later in the day.
- Exceptions to the Rule:
- Repeat Violations: If you repeat the same violation on the same day (e.g., speeding in another location), you can be fined again.
- Interstate Travel: If you’re travelling across states and lose the challan receipt, traffic police in another state may fine you for the same offence because they have no record of your prior penalty.
- Overspeeding as an Exception:
- Overspeeding is a dynamic violation that depends on your driving at any given time and place. Thus, you can be fined multiple times for overspeeding within the same day if caught in different instances.
Understanding Double Jeopardy
The term “double jeopardy” is derived from Article 20(2) of the Indian Constitution. It ensures that no individual is punished twice for the same offence. However, this law applies primarily to criminal proceedings and not to regulatory penalties like traffic fines.
Traffic challans are classified as civil penalties, not criminal offences, which is why double jeopardy rules are interpreted differently in this context.
Real-Life Scenarios Where You May Face Fines
To make this topic easier to understand, here are some hypothetical scenarios:
- Scenario 1:
- You’re fined for driving without a seatbelt in the morning.
- If the same traffic police officer or department stops you later that day, they cannot fine you again for the same reason if you show proof of your earlier challan.
- Scenario 2:
- You’re caught overspeeding on a highway in the morning and fined.
- Later that day, while driving on another road, you overspeed again and are caught. In this case, you can be fined twice because overspeeding is treated as an independent offence each time.
- Scenario 3:
- You’re travelling from Delhi to Uttar Pradesh and are fined in Delhi for jumping a red light.
- If you fail to carry your challan receipt and are stopped in Uttar Pradesh, you may be fined again for the same offence since the authorities have no record of your earlier penalty.
What Should You Do If You’re Fined?
To avoid confusion and ensure you’re not fined unfairly, follow these steps:
- Keep Challan Receipts: Always keep a copy of your challan receipt after paying a fine. If it’s a digital challan, save the receipt on your phone.
- Stay Informed: Be aware of the rules and carry valid documents like a driving license, insurance, pollution under control (PUC) certificate, and vehicle registration.
- Ask Questions: If a traffic police officer tries to fine you again for the same offence, politely explain the situation and show proof of your earlier challan.
- Appeal Unfair Fines: If you believe you’ve been fined unfairly, you can challenge the challan by approaching the traffic court or relevant authorities.
FAQs on Traffic Fines in India
1. Can traffic police stop you without a reason?
Yes, traffic police can stop vehicles for random checks to verify documents like a driving license, registration certificate, and insurance.
2. Are traffic challans valid nationwide?
Yes, e-challans issued in one state are valid across India, but you must carry proof of payment to avoid being fined again.
3. Can I refuse to pay the fine on the spot?
Yes, you can refuse to pay on the spot and instead choose to pay online or contest the fine in court.
4. Is overspeeding treated differently?
Yes, overspeeding is treated as a fresh offence each time it occurs, so you can be fined multiple times in a day.
Why Is It Important to Follow Traffic Rules?
Traffic rules are designed to ensure safety and reduce accidents. Violating these rules not only puts your life at risk but also endangers others on the road. With stricter penalties under the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019, traffic violations can lead to heavy fines, suspension of your driving license, or even imprisonment in severe cases.
Key Takeaways
- You cannot be fined twice in one day for the same traffic offence unless you repeat the violation or lose proof of your earlier challan.
- Overspeeding and interstate travel are exceptions to this rule.
- Always carry valid documents and challan receipts to avoid unnecessary fines.
- Traffic fines are civil penalties and do not fall under the criminal double jeopardy law.
By staying informed and following the rules, you can avoid unnecessary fines and contribute to safer roads.
